Home » Taxes » What Is The Progressive Consumption Tax?

What Is The Progressive Consumption Tax?

October 20, 2023
Bill Kimball

These special rules apply to imports of goods generally, and imports of services and other items to businesses. The PCT for imported goods is intended to be collected at the border, much like a customs duty. In addition, “reverse charge” rules apply to certain services and other items performed or done outside of the United States, but used within the United States in a trade or business. It is important to keep in mind that the full budgetary and distributional impact of the PCTA has not been evaluated by the Joint Committee on Taxation.

No tax is completely neutral, because taxing any activity will cause people to do less of it and more of other things. For instance, the income tax creates a “tax wedge” between the value of a person’s labor and what the person receives (after-tax income). As a consequence, people work less—and choose more leisure—than they would in a world with no taxes. An excise tax is a sales tax that applies to a specific class of goods, typically alcohol, tobacco, gasoline , or tourism. The tax rate varies according to the type of good and quantity purchased and is typically unaffected by the person who purchases it.

Is A State With No Income Tax Better Or Worse For Your Finances?

The levy equals the present value of the taxes the elderly would have paid under a consumption tax. 1.Consumption tax—Replacing an income tax with a consumption tax sharply favors the young and future generations over the older generations. As such, it leads to large increases in saving, investment, capital stock, productivity, and wages before tax. Consumption tax critics on the right frequently argue that such a tax would lead to great tax-code complexity very quickly.

The United States is a clear outlier by not having a federal consumption tax and consumption tax revenues making up less than 20 percent of total tax revenues across all levels of government. Previously introduced consumption-based tax proposals include the “USA Tax” , the “FairTax” and the “X Tax” (a two-part tax that taxes businesses through a subtraction method VAT and taxes individual wage income progressively).

Over the past week Libertarian Party presidential nominee Gary Johnson has promoted erasing the tax code in favor of a national sales tax on goods and services purchased. He’s quite right that his proposed form of taxation is far superior to graduated income tax concepts proposed by Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. Let’s look at a specific example to get a better understanding of how consumption taxes work. In the U.S., a special tax—specifically an excise tax—is levied on tobacco products.

Elimination of the seller’s burden to determine and document whether a buyer is exempt from sales tax. Under a VAT, unless the item transferred is zero-rated or the seller is exempt, VAT is charged on the sale of the good or service; it is up to the buyer to obtain a credit if they are entitled to one.

Consumption Tax Revenue Trends, 2000

A wealth tax can be narrowly or widely defined, and depending on the definition of wealth, the base for a wealth tax can vary. Taxable transactions include almost all goods, services, and other items.

Our editors and reporters thoroughly fact-check editorial content to ensure the information you’re reading is accurate. Our editorial team does not receive direct compensation from our advertisers. Kenneth Chavis IV, CFP®, provides guidance to business owners, entertainers, professional athletes and medical doctors on growing and protecting their wealth. The disparity is explained by what is known as the imputed rental value of a home. A homeowner could choose to rent the home to others in exchange for money, but instead chooses to live in the home. Therefore, the homeowner is also consuming housing by not permitting renters to pay for and occupy the home.

  • Our mission is to provide readers with accurate and unbiased information, and we have editorial standards in place to ensure that happens.
  • The consumption tax model reverses this paradigm, as money is only taxed when spent, which can encourage people to spend less and save more.
  • Except for the United States, all countries that are members of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development —countries with advanced economies similar to that of the United States—have a consumption tax.
  • The national median sales tax base reaches 34.25 percent of personal income.
  • Low- and middle-income consumers would receive additional rebates to further offset the burden of the PCT.

Revenue trends can also be impacted in that VAT often applies to the price, which includes excise taxes. If the VAT rate is increased, the goods subject to both VAT and excise may see lower sales due to price effects. Though a higher VAT rate would result in more consumption tax revenues overall, there could be slightly lower excise tax revenues. However, countries vary in the proportion of the consumption tax revenues made up by VAT, sales taxes, or excise taxes as seen in Figure 2. A new report from ProPublica argues that wealthy taxpayers face low effective tax rates as a portion of their wealth and mentions taxing unrealized capital gains or imposing a wealth tax.

Get The Best Rates

The tax amount is usually ad valorem, that is, it is calculated by applying a percentage rate to the price of a sale. When a tax on goods or services is paid to a governing body directly by a consumer, it is usually called a use tax. Often laws provide for the exemption of certain goods or services from such taxes. The implication of this literature is that individual cities and states whose citizens live close to state borders may find that excise taxes reduce domestic sales but have little impact on consumption. Excise taxes set at the national level would prevent the race to the bottom, but at the cost of preventing states from tailoring such tax policy to their circumstances.

  • In economic downturns, consumption activity tends to decline less than incomes, so governments that rely more on revenue from consumption taxes are under less pressure to run significant deficits.
  • State-level tax rates range from 2.9 percent in Colorado to 7.25 percent in California.
  • Businesses would necessarily be subject to new PCT reporting requirements.
  • For this reason, a consumption tax would be less neutral between work and leisure than the current income tax.
  • A wealth tax can be narrowly or widely defined, and depending on the definition of wealth, the base for a wealth tax can vary.
  • 2.Wage tax—In this substitution, the elderly gain relative to the young and future generations.

New Zealand raises the lowest share of revenue (2.5 percent) and the United States raises the lowest as a share of GDP (0.8 percent). Policymakers should ensure that consumption taxes only apply to final purchases of goods and services and that business inputs are untaxed. If an individual owns an asset like a stock or a small business, they do not pay taxes on the increased value of that asset until they realize the gain through a sale. Until they sell, any gain in the value of a stock or a business is a “paper gain,” meaning they have not received proceeds on which to be taxed.

Excise Tax

The differences in the VRR levels reflect the disparities in the application of reduced rates and exemptions among the OECD countries. However, recent research shows that reduced rates and exemptions are not an effective way of achieving such objectives.

The practical objection to a consumption tax used to be that it is too complicated to monitor the amounts that people save or dissave each year. But that actually can be done quite easily, as several decades of experience with IRAs, 401s, and other special savings vehicles have shown. Moving to a complete consumption tax system for the individual tax code would entail little more than allowing universal, unlimited IRAs for everyone and doing away with penalties for early withdrawals. Individuals could continue with the IRAs and 401s they currently have or roll them over into the new plans.

Help us achieve our vision of a world where the tax code doesn’t stand in the way of success. As a 501 nonprofit, we depend on the generosity of individuals like you. Other types of commercial activities subject to the PCT include the commercial activities of nonprofits and governments, which will also be required to comply with the provisions of the PCT. Erin Gobler is a personal finance expert and journalist who seeks to make the financial services industry more accessible by breaking down complicated financial topics in simple terms. We’re transparent about how we are able to bring quality content, competitive rates, and useful tools to you by explaining how we make money. Bankrate follows a strict editorial policy, so you can trust that our content is honest and accurate. Our award-winning editors and reporters create honest and accurate content to help you make the right financial decisions.

Thus, a VAT can be an easier system for removing the tax on producer goods. See Appendix A for examples of how the three types of VAT operate and compare to a retail sales tax . As for the argument related to the above that a consumption tax would perhaps force the lowest earners to pay more in taxes than they already do, never explained is why this would be a bad outcome. Everyone should know intimately the cost of government, and this is true regardless of income. Maybe, just maybe, if every American were to feel the oppressive burden of excessive government with every purchase, more Americans would vote for smaller, less intrusive government. Consumption taxes are taxes on the purchase of goods and services designed to tax individuals when they spend money rather than when they earn it. Excise taxes are commonly levied on cigarettes, alcoholic beverages, soda, gasoline, insurance premiums, amusement activities, and betting, and make up a relatively small and volatile portion of state and local tax collections.

Consumption Taxes In Brief

We would appreciate input from all stakeholders on this issue and on all aspects of the Act’s income tax reforms. Both income and consumption taxes are taxes on your money, but they apply at entirely different times. An income tax applies when you earn money such as wages, interest and dividends. Consumption taxes apply at the time goods and services are purchased and sold. It’s worth noting that California has the highest sales tax in the nation, so this example would look quite different in other states. Only a handful of states have a sales tax of 7 percent or higher, and a few states have no sales at all.

What is a positive externality?

A positive externality occurs when a benefit spills over. So, externalities occur when some of the costs or benefits of a transaction fall on someone other than the producer or the consumer.

In Appendix Tables 7 and following tables, tax rates are shown as a percentage of price or in U.S. dollars to allow comparison. Individual countries may, however, utilize both specific and ad valorem components in their design. Saskatchewan expanded its registration requirements for certain out-of-province sellers and British Columbia plans to do the same, starting from April 2021. Online platforms that facilitate and collect the payment or sell in the province of Saskatchewan the products or services taxed under the PST are required to register and collect the PST. The example in Figure 1 provides an ideal scenario for both VAT and sales tax.

Finally, paying taxes on a transactional basis under the credit invoice method means the PCT can become more and more automated as technology improves. As we move away from a cash economy, for instance, payment at the cash register could be translated to immediate remittance of tax to the government, greatly lowering the tax gap. The same can’t be said for subtraction method consumption taxes, which are not collected on a transaction-by-transaction basis. The PCTA was introduced in the 113th Congress and the 114th Congress to give legislators, policymakers, and all taxpayers an opportunity to see what this type of tax reform would look like.

Most analyses comparing the United States corporate tax rate to the corporate tax rate of other OECD countries do not take into account the fact these countries also impose a GST or VAT. Below is a table that compares current U.S. tax rates, OECD country averages, and rates imposed under the PCTA. The Progressive Consumption Tax Act was previously introduced in the 113th Congress and 114th Congress to provide an opening for discussion and an opportunity to review legislative language for this type of comprehensive tax reform. Overall, the PCTA shows how a progressive consumption tax can make our tax code fairer and more effective. Under the PCTA, most households would be exempt from any income tax and thus would be able to save tax free. A consumption tax is one that applies to the sale or purchase of a good or service.

Consumption Tax

The Progressive Consumption Tax changes the way we look at our tax system and revenues needed to build roads and bridges and keep our nation safe. Rather than taxing most income, it would generate reasonable revenues by taxing the purchase of goods and services. The PCT is modelled after the modern goods and services taxes of Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development countries—countries with advanced economies similar to that of the United States. We overlay this international model with a progressive rebate for lower-income individuals and families. In the case of income taxes on your wages, your employer likely takes income taxes out of your paychecks before you even receive the money. While income taxes apply when you earn money, consumption taxes apply when you spend it.

In addition, three-quarters of OECD countries levy a lower rate on small breweries. The federal Goods and Services Tax and the Harmonized Sales Tax applied in Canada and its provinces discussed in the previous chapter operate as a VAT, but the Provincial Sales Tax is a sales tax. However, in Colombia and Turkey, the exemption only applies to individuals and not to businesses. On the other hand, the United Kingdom has a VAT threshold of $124,935 that is almost twice the average VAT threshold for OECD countries (approximately $57,020). France, Poland, Lithuania, Slovak Republic, Japan, Italy, and Ireland also have particularly high thresholds of more than $90,000. Taxes can apply to what people earn, what they save, what they own, and what they buy.

Alternatively, if the individual puts the $6,500 in a Roth IRA and buys the same bonds, he gets the $325 in interest payments tax free and has $6,825 of potential consumption at the end of year one . In that case, he invests the entire $10,000 and pays no tax immediately.

Consumption Tax

The different experiences could also be explained by differing excise tax policies. However, we have limited historical data on excise tax rates that would be needed to answer this question.

More On The Pct

He writes about taxes and investing and has been published in the Journal of Accountancy and Fraud Magazine. Joshua has a master’s of public administration in forensic accounting from John Jay College.